The remedies for capitalism
Mon 25 April 2011
, Paul Polman, Unilever/McKinsey
It is a sign of the world in which we live that the word ‘crisis’ should appear so often in the introduction to Dominic Barton’s well-argued critique of capitalism. But what we have experienced over recent years is not so much a crisis of capitalism as a crisis of ethics, Unilever chief Paul Polman says.
As Dominic Barton acknowledges, capitalism itself remains the ‘greatest engine of prosperity ever devised.’ The issue, to pursue the analogy, is that maintenance of the financial engine has too often been left in the hands of young, untrained apprentices.
The central thesis of the article is that the ‘short-termism’ of so much modern business—‘quarterly capitalism’—lies at the heart of many of today’s problems.
No quarterly reporting
I agree and have said so many times, occasionally to my cost. At Unilever, words have been backed with action. We have aligned management incentives for the long term and invested heavily in R&D to build our pipeline of innovations. In addition, we have moved away from quarterly profit reporting; since we don’t operate on a 90-day cycle for advertising, marketing, or investment, why do so for reporting?
Resisting the game
And as Dominic Barton acknowledges, we have also been among those companies ‘to resist playing the game’ when it comes to issuing guidance. The share price may have fallen on the day we announced an end to guidance but is now 35 percent higher. Nothing in the intervening two years has persuaded me that this was the wrong thing to do. We will therefore go on resisting.
Prescriptions for change
For all these reasons, it is difficult to argue with Dominic Barton’s prescriptions for change—management incentives that encourage a focus on the long term, a broader form of stakeholder capitalism, and stronger, better-informed boards of directors.
These will all go a long way to addressing the problems of short-term capitalism.
They are necessary. But they are not sufficient. Changes in policy will mean little if not accompanied by changes in behavior. That’s why we need a different approach to business—a new model led by a generation of leaders with the mind-set and the courage to tackle the challenges of the future.
Continue Paul Polman’s response to Dominic Barton’s essay Long Term Capitalism here.
About the author
Columns from this author
Columns in Money
- The remedies for capitalism (25-04-2011, Paul Polman)
- Capitalism for the long term (19-04-2011, Dominic Barton, McKinsey/ Harvard Business Review)
- Review: 'The four pillars of investing' (16-04-2010, Alberta Opoku)
- ‘The Total Money Makeover’ (26-02-2010, Alberta Opoku)
- Make your money work at home too (21-12-2009, Marie-Pauline Luger & Dorieke Mulder)
- A tricky question (05-09-2009, Henriëtte Prast)
Articles in Money
- Are Men the Real Winners with the Rise of Female Breadwinners? (09-04-2012)
- Wage gap still there, unless you are a house-sitter (26-03-2012)
- Emotion Analytics: The Missing Ingredient in Risk Management (13-02-2012)
- Mine's Bigger than Yours: Challenges of Being a Female Breadwinner (05-12-2011)
- 10 Things Baby Boomers Won't Tell you (21-11-2011)
- Negotiate for…your family, friends, colleagues (15-11-2011)
- 5 Tips to remember next time you negotiate a raise (07-11-2011)
- Female leaders share advice at Wall Street Conference (24-10-2011)
- It - literally - doesn't pay to be nice (05-09-2011)
- Effect van loopbaanonderbreking op salaris vrouwen (18-07-2011)
- Aandeel e-shoppers in 2010 verder gestegen (04-07-2011)
- Leuk werk? Alleen geld telt... (27-06-2012)
- Serious Play: The Business of Social Currency (17-05-2011)
- Banksparen steeds populairder (02-05-2011)
- Remaking Portugal Telecom: An interview with CEO Zeinal Bava (03-05-2011)
- Inkomen Japanse vrouwen passeert dat van mannen (19-04-2011)
- Nu gaan vrouwen de best betaalde banen inpikken (11-04-2011)
- Too expensive? Don’t listen to that little voice (29-03-2011)
- Bedrijven scoren beter met vrouwen (22-03-2011)
- Vrouwen werken meer voor minder (15-03-2011)
- Whose money is it? (25-01-2011)
- Ladies, Should You Ask For It? (25-01-2011)
- Budgets are sexy (18-01-2011)
- Young British women reverse pay gap (12-12-2010)
- Lehman Sisters Wouldn't Have Failed (07-12-2010)
- Chocolate will be the future caviar (20-11-2010)
- Banking on gender diversity (08-11-2010)
- European employees: ‘management are fraudsters’ (19-05-2010)
- Women and money (03-04-2010)
- Making cash with ‘socialnomics’ (29-03-2010)
- ‘Can you afford your life?’ (25-03-2010)
- Review: The four pillars of investing (23-03-2010)
- Beat the tax office to it and start now! (09-03-2010)
- ‘Every quality has its price’ (02-02-2010)
- Suze Orman’s 2010 personal finance tips (22-01-2010)
- Success in your work, success in your wallet... (01-01-2010)
- Poll: I manage My Money at home... (01-01-2010)
- Your money and you: (01-01-2010)
- My money… (01-01-2010)